CH strikes again
Posted in Rants/Raves on 08/28/2004 04:05 pm by enjanerdSee? You shouldn’t call pregnant people fat either:
New York: Hi! Love your column! I am about five months pregnant (first time). I have now had two people say to me, “Wow you’re really big!” or “You look really pregnant!” And then act astonished that the baby isn’t due for four more months. I find this incredibly annoying. I have gained about five pounds more than I should (according to the books), but I am trying really hard to eat well and exercise. Any suggestions on how to handle this. Right now I just want to sock them, which I think is probably a bad way to handle it.
Thanks!
Carolyn Hax: You’d make your point, though.
Still, I’m not sure you’d be right. Yes being told you’re really big is somewhat insensitive, considering what society currently thinks of women and largeness, but: you’re PREGNANT. Big is in your belly. Big is good. Big is a compliment. Unless they ask whether you’re carrying a twin in your butt, in which case it’s not a compliment.
Columbia, Md.: Ok, after reading the response from the “really big” pregnant woman, I wonder if I have been horribly rude all these years. When a woman I know is pregnant, and excited about it, typically when I see her around 4-5+ months (especially if I found out the news via phone) I say (excitedly) “Wow! You really look pregnant/are really showing!” or something like that. To me, it’s like admiring shoes she bought and is really psyched about, but am I wrong? I’m a woman, and only do this with people I consider good friends if it matters.
Carolyn Hax: Idunno, said by the right person in the right way, just about anything is okay, and said by the wrong person the wrong way, just about anything is offensive. I don’t want to say, “Yeah, that’s bad,” and end up making you bite your tongue on genuine expressions of admiration.
Suggestions for the stumped: For your good friends, you can’t lose with, “Wow, you look beautiful”– and if they don’t look beautiful or arent’ good friends, “Wow, you look so happy.”
Anywhere: Hi Carolyn,
So here’s a problem I never thought I’d have. An unintentional side effect of a medical issue is that I have lost a lot of weight in the last year. I am eating three square meals a day, taking medicine, and working with my doctor to get back to a healthy weight. In the meantime, co-workers will come up to me and remark, “Gee, you sure are skinny” or something like that. This is really awkward for me because I really don’t know how to respond. I don’t know some of these people well and I don’t feel that I should have to disclose my medical history on demand. Plus, I’m never sure if the remark is intended as a misguided compliment or as an implication that I am purposefully hurting myself. What’s a good response to this? “Mind your own business” seems kind of harsh, but on the other hand, I would never go up to someone and say “Gee, you look pudgy today.”
Thoughts?
Thanks.
Carolyn Hax: I imagine some mean it as a compliment and some are expressing concern. To all I’d try just saying, “Thanks.” Then neither of you will know what you’re thanking them for, and you can use that confusion to change the subject.
Wow. Her chat was really good this week. Stop pointing at people and laughing. Well, unless they’re being angry. Then laugh away! :) -J.


